I have always been a proponent of the idea that you can have whatever opinion you want, but you should have a reason to think that way, other than that someone told you or that you saw it on a internet meme.
As I was dressing after a workout at our local recently ‘upscaled and modernized’ club, I noticed on the flatscreen in the locker room that there was a video of a gorgeous footprint-sized Pacific NW forest spring with enticing and presumably very cold and clear water tumbling over pristine and undisturbed mossy rocks surrounded by ferns and trunks of large hardwood trees. Soon there appeared written over this scene in advancing bold type, a description of the water served in the cooler near the weight room I had just left. The rolling ad described our local water as being contaminated with trace, but safe, levels of bad things like lead, arsenic, and fluorine. As the ad rolls forth, it describes how the water served HERE is not like that water depicted on the screen, in that it has been forced thru “carbon block” purification to extract all those ‘toxins’ that will surely build up in your system if you drink as much water as healthy people do. As my skeptical mind tends to do, I mused at the depiction of the very source of life on earth, that of fresh tumbling water. The ad was depicting this inarguably ‘natural’ forest scene as toxic, and that since we are so smart, we can make this water healthy for you to drink.
But the next ad was reminding me to stop in at the Smoothie bar to get an all-natural drink concocted with unprocessed fruits and grasses, shipped fresh, by plane, from natural orchards in Chile, and rain forests in Brazil and Guatemala. How intellectually prostitutional is the thought that whatever happens to have been freshly deposited on the leaves and grasses imported urgently from Guatemala is good for me, but somehow the water in this stream is toxic and needs to be remanufactured and processed to save me from poisoning myself with it!
In case you are interested, check out the label on the bottle of water that you drink. Likely you will find it is bottled from somebody’s city or commercial water source, often from a tap. May not even be as good as what you get from your own city. Just FYI.
And for the Fluorine content of water? Consider that seawater is quite high in Fluorine ion, about 0.001 g per kg of water, AKA 1ppm. The relative percent of the dissolved substances in seawater is relatively constant around the world, even tho the density or total salinity may change. Oddly enough, this is the amount also found in ‘sea salt’ and the target range for communities that fluorinate water supplies. The point? The healthy and rejuvinating sea spray you feel at the coast is laced with fluorine. Maybe Fluorine is not such a bad guy after all.
But back to my story. The next ad on the flat screen TV is for me to go to the spa to get a facial peel. The models on the video were coating faces with chemical ‘mud’ that required the applicant to wear gloves. The chemicals applied were toxic enough that the mud, when peeled, removed the outer layer of skin, and caused an increase in cell turnover of the underlying younger layers. The result of this inflammatory treatment is a “new, healthier-looking you”. In the same video as the water propaganda.
As you leave the club, you will be invited to ingest Vitamin D. One of my favorite non-science recommendations. Our skin is very well capable, thru a complex and tightly-controlled mechanism, to generate all the D you need at any given point, even if sunlight intensity is low, such as in the Pacific NW. In fact, most of people tested in the NW during the winter will test ‘low’. The problem? Vitamin D, as with A, E, and K, are not soluble in water/blood, and is not stored there. Testing blood for D levels is like checking someone’s wallet for cash to see if he is rich or not. Rarely do rich people carry all their money in their pocket. The point? Blood testing for D is irrelevant to body stores. Let your skin take care of it. Get 10 minutes outside every day, and skip the D.
The shelves will also contain various supplements like CoQ-10, sold as an energy-producing enzyme. ALL the energy produced for my recent workout was produced by a pathway in mitochondria that is an intricately controlled function of CoQ-10. But eating it, thinking that it will somehow wind up in your mitochondrial membrane ready to make you a boatload of energy, simplifies the mechanism absurdly.
Which brings up another absurdity “If I can’t say it and God didn’t make it, I won’t eat it”. We make up names for all the chemicals. We made up the name ‘water’, ‘mud’ and ‘salt’. We made up the name ‘aspartame’, ‘sugar’, and ‘high fructose corn syrup’. The chemical name for Vitamin A is difficult to say, hence the name ‘A’. Ever wonder why we refer to a ‘B complex’? Ever wonder what B1, B6 and B12 are? Have you ever even heard of B5 or B9? I hope that if you ever used this as a description of healthy vs unhealthy supplements, that you stop saying it. It doesn’t make you look smart.
So much for my healthy trip to the gym. But I still enjoyed my workout, even tho it was a contrived set of movements using chunks of metal that I pick up in various ways for the express purpose of making me hurt, knowing full well that there are machines that can pick up thousands of them at the same time for years unceasingly. I exhaled about 0.87kg CO2 greenhouse gas during my hour workout. But the point isn’t to get the weights from one place to another. In fact, an hour after I picked them up, I put them back in exactly the same spot where I found them. An odd sport indeed.




























